Patients with new cancer diagnoses are faced with an early
decision of lumpectomy and radiation versus mastectomy. While conserving the breast is an appealing
idea, it does not work well for many women, and can result in a deformed breast
that is difficult to improve. I have
also seen a number of cases that developed cancer in the remaining breast
tissue left behind after lumpectomy in spite of radiation treatment. Nevertheless, I tend to advise the option of
breast preservation if it is likely to
give a good cosmetic result. If not,
the mastectomy, which removes almost all of the breast tissue from the cancer
site, may be the better option.
Patients who are potential candidates for mastectomy should,
ideally, see the plastic surgeon early on in the workup process to ascertain
the role of plastic surgery for them. There
is no substitute for a detailed and thorough examination, assessing each
patient for options involving both implant approaches as well as body tissue
reconstructions. I have heard so many
women say, “I wish I knew that before . . .,” as they had never seen a plastic
surgeon until they were already healing from the mastectomy. As a general rule, use of implants and
expanders are shorter procedures involving less hospitalization. Implants are limited in how they can be
placed and used to shape a breast, do not fare well in areas that have had or
will have radiation, and can be difficult to match to an opposite “natural”
breast. Because of these limitations,
they often work better in cases of double mastectomies.
Tissue reconstructions can require longer operative and
hospitalization times, but offer advantages in shaping and in radiated
areas. Their success relies on adequate
blood flow into the tissues, a factor
that the plastic surgeon is attentive to throughout the surgery and post-operative
period. The two most common sources of body
tissue are the tummy and the back areas.
Not everyone is a good candidate for this approach; your plastic surgeon
can guide you.
Some words of advice if you are facing breast cancer or know
someone who is . . .
1)
Take a deep breath, and try to stay focused to
make the best choices you can.
Experienced plastic surgeons know that you are sometimes under short
time constraints to make decisions about your care, and they will try to give
you as much information as possible.
Meet with them as early as possible.
2)
With the current state of chemotherapy and
additional treatments, survival with this diagnosis has made great progress in
the last few decades.
3)
The changes in your body tissue that result from
a course of radiation may never go away.
They may have a major impact on your reconstruction in the future.
4)
If a lumpectomy will likely deform your breast
in a way that could disappoint you, think carefully about whether the
mastectomy option would be a better choice.
5)
All other factors being equal, the body tissue
reconstruction frequently offers the best long-term result.
6)
If you need reconstruction after mastectomy,
good integration of your plastic surgeon with the other members of the team is
a strong advantage.
Saul R. Berger, MD, FACS